Hear from Doug Sarney from MRI Software and Maggie Houghton from Hyde, many thanks to Shelley Hathaway-Batt from Clarion for chairing
How to identify those in poverty
Identifying those in poverty is key for knowing who may need some support. One way of doing this that came up in the discussion is mapping customers most exposed to the cost of living crisis (desktop exercise), i.e. who are already in debt, those with a disability and might be using facilities more, and those in energy inefficient homes.
The biggest obstacle faced in identifying those in poverty is often having poor quality data. Time was another challenge that was raised; for example, going out to the residents and asking them what they need is a massive undertaking, so how do we best do this. Options include the use of existing research. The importance of upskilling all staff in all teams to understand indicators and to be able to give quality advice and signpost/refer was also highlighted.
We heard how looking at what previous support, such as the emergency support fund (fuel vouchers and energy vouchers), has been previously used by residents as an indicator of potential future support needs. As well as the importance of proactively reaching out to those in situations that we know to be precarious, such as contacting residents who are signing up to Universal Credit for the first time. This also lead to a discussion about how most measures and solutions are short-term and how can we be innovative and disruptive? We need to make real changes, i.e. reduce responsive repairs service and housing management visits so we can reduce rent.
The idea of having a different approach to GDPR and the impact this has was also raised, for example, restricting how much we can tell residents about services and how much work we can do to identify and reach out to resident groups.
Lastly, the benefits of partnerships out of the sector, e.g. National Energy Action, local councils etc were also underlined as a way of taking the pressure off housing associations to create solutions.
Fuel poverty
Energy Redress fuel vouchers have been incredibly valuable, but colleagues are increasingly concerned about non-pre-payment meter residents and how to direct financial support to them as we move into winter. Longhurst are developing a Community Improvement Fund to provide an internal funding mechanism for non-PPM residents, and working creatively with social value elements in procurement processes to direct support for those experiencing fuel poverty.
Some housing associations are taking a consortium approach (for example, Independent East) to collect information and data about issues facing residents and what support they need/want. Using the data, they will look at how they can pool resources across the consortium to meet some of those needs, such as jointly funding a new role to work across all the housing associations. There was also mention of how housing associations could test the use of tech such as Switchee to see what insights it gives and as a communication method direct to residents’ homes.
It was mentioned that it is not necessarily the customers who are asking for help that housing associations are most concerned about, but rather those residents they never hear from. Again GDPR was recognised as an issue but a few approaches being taken are:
- Engaging with community groups where residents are already going for support, and working with them to train up ‘community champions’ who can provide low-level debt/energy support, or signpost to Community Investment teams within HAs
- Bang on the Table – customer engagement software being used by Longhurst. Residents give permission to be contacted when signing up to the platform which allows Community Investment teams to reach out and offer support
- Getting Behind Closed Doors, Wrekin Housing Trust – making contact with residents who they don’t hear from, ensuring they have the correct communication preferences set including what channel they prefer, widening their choice of channels, e.g. setting up a TikTok to appeal to younger residents
Food insecurity
It is now evident that it is no longer just those in poverty or unemployment; many of those seeking food support are in employment, but an overall increase in costs is hitting them across every expense, and now at the basic need level. The UK Harvest Survey – supports the idea that everyone is affected, not just the poorest.
Crisis funds and short-term solutions are a sticking plaster, and there is a need to focus on a more rounded cause and need, and have services or direct support for the full picture. For example, Orbit have a triage system and dedicated team for residents who can assess their full needs and they are currently reaching around 20,000 this way. Some larger housing associations voiced that they need a national solution as well as access to local solutions or insight
Three keys themes came out of the discussion
Choice
- Just as there are lots of different sizes, structures, types of housing associations and resident needs, there needs to be solutions to meet the different needs and allow the residents to choose what works for them.
- Pantry’s / Food Banks: Residents need access to free food – Abri, Sussex, CAB all had local examples. Short-term / emergency options are also needed, but it was noted that supplies are no longer as forthcoming. Funders are no longer focusing on food as the main fund to support. Many organisations are having to fundraise themselves e.g. Salvation Army.
- Community Supermarket: Shopping for fresh items for a smaller cost supports the dignity of residents and in turn, helps their mental health
- Community Café: Access free or very cheap food, as well as a place to meet and support which helps with wellbeing
- Community gardens and well-being gardens work for bringing the community together
- Food Co-operative: L&Q are looking to set this up to replace banks/pantries
It was noted that all of the above also offer employment opportunities for those in the community. At a hyperlocal level, this supports local knowledge, and community environment along with helping to identify the needs or requirements of residents to adapt to cultural needs
Communication
- Lack of knowledge of what is available from housing associations, community projects, etc as well as how to access them
- The message needs to be taken to residents; this could be via frontline staff through leaflets, conversations, individual knowledge (CAB), proactive door-knocking
- Another approach is an exhibition van in the community (similar to an old-style neighbourhood office)
- Language of how you talk about food insecurity is vital in order to remove the stigma, so people access or ask for help. Supermarkets as opposed to food banks are preferred, due to the dignity of doing your shopping and paying for it, even if it is a small amount.
- A need to talk about reducing food wastage and redistribution rather than a donation, being sensitive to needs of different cultures and their food
Partnership
- Have local knowledge of all services so that housing associations can signpost
- An emphasis on partnering rather than starting something new. Consider what is already there, or has someone already got a successful model?
- Education: Where, how and when to get support for food and other services
- Link to the extension of food poverty into Hygiene Banks, School uniform banks /swap etc so they don’t have to choose between these items and food
Impact on mental health
The group considered mental health in three themes based on MRI’s research:
- Worry
- Agency
- Knowing
The group discussed whether ‘knowing’ about support services in itself will help improve mental health more so than actually receiving the support. For example, knowing there is an Energy Hardship Fund could be enough to reduce the stress and anxiety of fuel bills. Abri shared there plans to provide a directory of support services to their residents which includes all support for mental health and beyond. They are working on how to make this as accessible as possible to residents.
The group briefly discussed the effect of referrals on mental health. Catalyst’s ‘no wrong door’ policy was shared as a great example to minimise the uncertainty for residents. Providing easy support to account for the frustration of areas out of their control such as applying for universal credit. The recent research from CPAG: Navigating the UC system report was discussed as an example of how accessing financial help can lead to issues with mental health
Digital / data poverty / exclusion
Understanding your residents’ needs around data and digital is critical. One colleague talked about a digital needs survey they had undertaken recently, which highlighted that the biggest challenge for residents was devices. They are working with the Good Things Foundation with their national device bank – devices no longer needed by organisations, staff or friends can be recycled here.
One colleague mentioned that they had built-in provision of laptops/devices into contracts with suppliers, as part of their social value requirement. Another colleague talked about the lack of coverage in rural areas which would affect residents’ ability to use digital to contact their HAs. If people can’t engage this way, then how can we enable them to talk with us, noting the importance of being able to talk to a person. This was affirmed by two others; one mentioned the use of 0800 numbers, with residents ending up waiting for 40 minutes before they spoke to someone. The other reinforced the importance of face-to-face; even though residents might be tech-savvy, they don’t want to do everything digitally!
We touched on the issue of data – devices are great, but we’re hearing that some residents are unable to use digital food vouchers because they don’t have enough data available on their phones. Free data is being provided to 500,000 people here: National Databank – Good Things Foundation
Finally, there is the issue of being able to inform residents about these initiatives – colleagues talked about being inhibited from emailing residents because of GDPR requirements, although this was challenged by many others. HACT were asked to investigate this further.
We ended by talking about the benefit of engaging in this way and sharing that HACT will be hosting a digital poverty alliance network through our Centre for Excellence in Community Investment. More details on this will be shared with delegates.