Listen to HACT’s Business Development Director Matthew Grenier and Head of Services Dr Frances Harkin about the research on community spaces, the development of the framework and the next considerations for any organisations who manage community spaces.
The use and management of community centres across the social housing sector
Within housing associations, community centres can be seen as expensive to run as well as not producing much financial value for the organisation. This is because, quite often, they enable grassroots organisations to use them for peppercorn rent, so they don’t generate significant income. As a result, they are costly assets to maintain, and without a social value framework, it would be difficult for some organisations to justify keeping them open.
A quote from our recent report that is essentially: if you don’t have a space for the community to come into, then there is no community. Community centres play a critical role for communities.
Developing a framework to measure their impact
This framework was commissioned by a number of different organisations, all of which are listed in the actual report. These organisations provided us with funding to develop a framework that was initially focused on community centres. However, as the research progressed, it evolved into a framework for community spaces more broadly. It’s not just about physical buildings; it’s also about the spaces that communities inhabit.
Primarily, our focus is on the social value metrics that organisations can use. However, there are also some non-social value metrics that, as yet, we can’t quantify but which remain important for organisations to monitor.
The framework enables organisations to identify which of these elements apply to them and to create a benchmark of the value that the community space provides. This allows organisations to use that information in internal discussions to justify retaining that community asset. That’s what we’re hoping will happen – that organisations will use this framework to view their community spaces with fresh eyes and understand that non-financial metrics are just as important as financial metrics.
Stakeholder focus
The framework looks at three different stakeholders who benefit from community spaces, and it is designed to consider these stakeholders in a structured way.
The framework explained
-
The individuals
First, it focuses on individuals. Because of the nature of the value outcomes in the UK Social Value Bank, it’s easier to quantify social value in many of these areas. This includes areas such as:
- Health outcomes (physical and mental health)
- Activities for education
- Employment initiatives
- Financial inclusion
- Social inclusion
Whatever activities are hosted in a community space, you can generate indicative or forecast social value for those activities. By conducting pre- and post-surveys, you can then evidence the actual social value that’s being created.
For many organisations, this will serve as an initial benchmarking exercise to understand the social value that has been created. This ties in with some of the work I’ve been doing with a few community centres in London, the Midlands, and the West Country, where I’ve helped them identify their social value and provided an indicative social value calculation based on the various activities happening in their spaces.
This can range from hosting coffee mornings to immigration advice, financial well-being sessions, and gyms, where community members can do moderate exercise on a cost-effective basis.
The calculations I’ve done for community centres have been very useful. For instance, one community centre used them in conversations with their local council about lease costs, demonstrating the social value they provided. Another engaged with local councils and health bodies to show how their community centre contributed significantly to delivering population-based health initiatives. In yet another case, we explored the potential for demolishing the community centre to build affordable housing.
However, our development appraisal calculations helped present a case to the council, who decided to keep the community centre open and build affordable housing in the car park instead. These efforts are crucial, especially considering the 15 years of local community infrastructure decimation that have recently occurred.
-
The community
The second area the framework addresses is the impact on the community itself. This includes factors such as:
- Volunteering
- Training
- Employment opportunities
- Access to community spaces
For some of these reasons, we do have values in the UK Social Value Bank, but for others, we don’t. In those cases, we recommend organisations gather observational data. This might include:
- Regular community centre usage statistics
- Free access to services
- A sense of community cohesion
- Community pride resulting from the presence of the community space
While some of these observations may be simple yes/no questions, the responses can be very valuable in demonstrating the usefulness and importance of the community space.
-
The organisation
The third area of focus is the impact on the organisation that owns the community space. For housing associations, community hubs are vital for effective customer engagement. As the sector becomes more aware of consumer regulations, it must be accessible for customers in as many ways as possible. Often, this means interacting in person at the local community hub rather than calling a call centre or emailing without assurance of a timely response.
Community centres also generate income, which is an important point to capture. This includes:
- Hiring out spaces
- Reducing management costs (often outsourced to third parties)
- Income from grants and donations as part of supply chain social value commitments
It’s about capturing all this information in one place to show the overall value of the community space to the organisation.
Sustainability and partnerships
The framework also includes considerations about the sustainability of the community space and partnerships. For many housing associations, having community spaces means collaborating with:
- Local grassroots organisations
- Local high street banks
- Other commercial outfits present in neighbourhoods
These partnerships highlight the social and economic value of maintaining community spaces.
The framework acknowledges that organisations won’t be able to capture every single outcome or every detail within each area. However, it offers support to organisations to identify the data that is easiest to gather and the elements that are most meaningful to them. It refers back to the seven principles of social value – organisations should capture what matters most to them, do it effectively, and ensure the evidence is clear and measurable.
What we hope to do next
We can work alongside organisations to establish an indicative social value baseline, which they can refine over time. The ultimate goal is to help them secure investment in community spaces, demonstrate social value, and continuously capture and evidence the community benefits that these spaces create. It may well be that organisations create even more social value than our indicative calculations initially suggest.