If you have a question, query or idea, we’d love to hear from you.
In April 2017, Orbit established Earn It, Don’t Burn It (EIDBI) as a two-year service, designed to enable customers to achieve a more financially secure future by developing their own long-term financial capability skills. The service had a focus on achieving sustainable behavioural change and support both Orbit customers and the wider community. EIDBI was delivered by We Are Digital as lead delivery partner and manager of the single point of access (SPOA) as well as six further regional delivery partners, via face-to-face and telephone appointment support.
Orbit commissioned HACT to carry out an independent evaluation of the Earn It, Don’t Burn It service in the last year of its service cycle. The evaluation framework is designed to provide an independent assessment of how Earn It, Don’t Burn It has been delivered in practice, its performance during the reporting period and learning that can be applied to future tendering exercise and service design to optimise impact in the future.
The headline findings focus on impact and service delivery and are as follows.
Outcomes, social value & impact
- Service users reported highest increase in the following behaviours: Having Enough Money Knowledge; Finding Best Deals Behaviour; Finding Best Deals Knowledge And change of Mindset;
- 1 service user became debt free and 11 maintained debt-free status. 4 service users achieved financial comfort and a further 12 improved their financial comfort levels;
- Service users achieved financial gain or savings worth £22,195. 6 service users achieved financial gains during both the first and second appointments, with the highest combined gain from both appointments reaching £1,584;
- Total social value created by the service was £30, 202. 1.2.2 Engagement
- The typical Earn It, Don’t Burn It service user who completed the journey is a white British woman between ages of 16 and 65 with no disability or issues with literacy/numeracy (46.03% of those completing the journey).
- From 524 referrals to the service, 222 people engaged and 96 (18.32%) completed the full customer journey. Most people dropped off during initial attempts to engage and before the first appointment. This is the key time in the service user journey to address in order to improve take-up of the service.
- Over a third (33.7%) of engaged customers were referred for further support, many of whom were signposted for mental health support.
Service delivery
- The service is filling a gap in financial capability provision using innovative approaches. Feedback from both delivery partners and service users has been overwhelmingly positive highlighting the value of the service to service users.
- In the current operating model, different types of delivery partners engage service users with different levels of need. As a result, there unlikely to be a one-size fits all model for the service. Subsequently, there have been some contract management challenges, with the service taking up more resource staff time both within Orbit and by delivery partners than anticipated.
- Take up of digital elements of the service (using financial management and budgeting apps) was not as high as expected, partly due to the already precarious financial position of service users and their reluctance to share bank details.