Book a chat with our team to talk through where you are, what’s possible and how to move forward with confidence.
In the first session of our Social Value Conference, we had expert speakers from procurement, employment and housing tackling the challenging subject of how social value is evolving and what organisations need to do now to be ready for the next decade.
In this blog, we’re revisiting the questions you’ve been asking, combining insights from our guest speakers with additional reflections and practical advice from the HACT social value team.
Over the past decade, social value has undergone a significant shift, moving from a fringe consideration to mainstream policy, becoming a core requirement in commissioning and procurement, and an increasingly visible measure of organisational credibility.
Despite this progress, social value too often stops at good intentions. Once contracts are awarded, follow-through is inconsistent at best — and, from my perspective working in delivery, this is where intention and reality most often diverge. The challenge now is not whether organisations understand social value, but whether they can deliver it in meaningful and measurable ways.
The discussions at our Social Value Conference didn’t end when the cameras stopped rolling. In the weeks since, I’ve found the same themes and challenges coming up again and again in discussions with social value managers, delivery teams and partners across the sector.
Rich Tyrie, CEO of Good People, put it plainly: “Unfortunately I think we’re heading the other way — towards transactional rather than transformational. It’s an inevitable consequence of social value starting to mainstream.”
The reason, he argued, is structural. Social Value Managers are “buckling under the weight of vast projects,” often single-handedly trying to coordinate delivery on behalf of large organisations. Until social value is properly resourced, the drift towards tick-box compliance will continue.
“[Until] we’re prepared to price it explicitly, contract it properly, and enforce it, like we enforce all the other commercial commitments, we’ll continue to see a race to the bottom. And we let organisations off the hook from creating the opportunities that our communities deserve.”
His case for transparent pricing is grounded in evidence. Good People places people with multiple barriers into employment for between £2,000 and £3,000 per year — and that placement generates a ten to fifteen times social return in year one. “The unit economics are there. What’s missing is a system willing to commission them and enforce them.”
“[Until] we’re prepared to price it explicitly, contract it properly, and enforce it, like we enforce all the other commercial commitments, we’ll continue to see a race to the bottom. And we let organisations off the hook from creating the opportunities that our communities deserve.”
Rich Tyrie
CEO, Good People
This may be the question that resonated most in the room — because almost everyone who works in social value has felt it.
The easy wins — a volunteer day, a charitable donation — get traction precisely because they are easy. The harder work — meaningful employment pathways for people facing barriers, genuine community partnerships — requires sustained effort and organisational support.
Mark Chadwick, Group Executive Director at Fusion21 was direct about what works. “Start from the board, start from having clear strategies, and use that as a lever for your procurement process and all these other processes to deliver against that. It’s a culture change.”
But what if that top-down commitment doesn’t exist yet? Both Chadwick and Tyrie pointed to the same approach: connect social value to things leadership already measures, whether that be staff retention, local reputation or ESG reporting.
In my experience, this only really starts to shift when you’re able to build the right relationships internally. I’d also suggest finding allies in finance and procurement – people who understand that social value commitments are contractual obligations, who will help shift these targets from an aspiration to a business requirement.
The shift happens when you connect social value to things
leadership already measures, whether that be staff retention,
local reputation or ESG reporting.
One of the most persistent failures in social value, is organisations attempting to build from scratch what already exists. Local community-led organisations, who are already delivering vital services, hold trust that new entrants can’t replicate, yet they’re frequently bypassed in favour of larger delivery partners.
The solution isn’t complicated in theory, even if it is difficult to execute. Start by mapping what already exists in a place before designing your own interventions. There needs to be a genuine commitment to partnership, where the community organisation is resourced and credited, not just consulted.
Liz Parsons, Programme Director – Community Partnerships at Amplius, offered the lived experience of Amplius’ health and housing partnership — Peabody, BPHA, Amplius, public health, and Be Active Bedfordshire working together across the NHS, local authorities, VCSE organisations, and resident and faith groups. “Social value is maximised not by just doing more, but doing the right things together, and not in isolation.” When parts of this system acted alone, the risk was duplication — or vulnerable residents falling through the cracks.
In my experience, this only really starts to shift when you’re able to build the right relationships internally. I’d also suggest finding allies in finance and procurement – people who understand that social value commitments are contractual obligations, who will help shift these targets from an aspiration to a business requirement.
“Social value is maximised not by just doing more, but doing the right things together, and not in isolation.”
Liz Parsons
Programme Director – Community Partnerships at Amplius,
GDPR is often invoked as a barrier to data sharing between organisations. Sometimes, that can be legitimate, but more often, it reflects a lack of understanding of what is actually permissible, and a tendency to use that as a reason to stop.
The main issue is frequently relational, not legal – organisations are reluctant to share data because they haven’t established trust. Building trust through sustained partnerships needs to happen before data even becomes part of the conversation, and data sharing agreements should reflect your genuine collaboration.
From a practical perspective, one of the most effective ways to do this is by involving your Data Protection Officer at the design stage, not after commitments are made, to help build a shared data infrastructure. The Amplius model — creating shared resources like the Insights Bank across multiple partner organisations — is more scalable than a web of bilateral DSAs. Clear governance, common data standards, and agreed access tiers means new partners can be onboarded with a single agreement rather than negotiating from scratch each time and ensures you establish a clear lawful basis before you start, not after.
Social value is moving towards credibility, towards measurable outcomes, towards accountability that extends well beyond the point of contract award. The question is who will be ready when that shift crystallises.
Organisations that treat social value as a compliance exercise will find themselves increasingly exposed — not because the rules will necessarily tighten overnight, but because communities, commissioners, and the public are becoming better at distinguishing genuine delivery from empty promises.
Those who will be ready in 2030 are the ones who start now: investing in outcome measurement infrastructure, building genuine partnerships with community organisations, having honest conversations about cost and resourcing, and embedding social value into governance and leadership accountability — not just into bid documents.
Book a chat with our team to talk through where you are, what’s possible and how to move forward with confidence.