6 July, 2026

It's not just about the margins

At this year’s Social Value Conference, a panel of leaders from banking, housing and economics explored a question that’s becoming impossible to ignore: Is finance reshaping social value—for better or for worse?

Matthew Grenier

Earlier this year, I had a conversation with an Sustainability Linked Loan (SLL) specialist at one of the leading UK banks. One of their clients had an SLL in place, with marginal discounts related to their social value metrics and had reported a significant uplift in their impact numbers. He was asking me why this might be the case. 

I explained that there could be two reasons: first, that they were doing more of the same, and being more impactful. Secondly, that they were using a wider range of value outcomes from across our value banks, demonstrating that these had been developed to enable housing associations to measure the impact of everything they do. 

It was with this in mind that we hosted a session at our social value conference in April and invited Steve Sze from Lloyds Bank, Anthony Homan from Orbit, and Ed Dallas from Simetrica-Jacobs to share their thoughts about what the growth in SLLs means for housing associations, lenders, and those providing the metrics. 

It was a fascinating conversation with some key messages. 

Don’t miss the bigger story. The margin discount is not the point. Focusing on these potential savings misses the bigger story. The real value of an SLL is what it does inside your organisation. At Orbit, having SLLs in place meant that the Treasury team now sits on the sustainability steering group. Finance and social value are no longer parallel conversations. They are the same one. In other words, the SLL made everyone across the organisation understand and value the importance of the impact they drive and why it should be measured. 

This is not a passing trend. The volume of SLLs is growing, not shrinking. The question is no longer whether finance will reshape social value. It already has. The question is how we reshape it together.

“Credibility is everything. Once a metric is linked to a loan, it stops being informative and becomes contractual. The methodology sitting behind it must be robust, transparent, consistent, and capable of independent assurance.

There is no shortcut here.”   

Matthew Grenier

Business Development Director, HACT

Measurement should not be a burden, and it must be taken seriously. The Newbridge Advisors research was clear: reporting should not be so onerous that it offsets the benefit of the discount itself. But that cuts both ways. Treating measurement as a box-ticking exercise is equally corrosive. Think about how complex your financial accounting is. That complexity does not stop you doing it properly. Neither should this. 

Proxy values change, so you will need to build in the flexibility. The UK Social Value Bank is a living tool. We launched version 7 in April, updating the wellbeing and Exchequer values in line with inflation and changes in individual income. At the same time, we are working on a suite of new value outcomes that will provide housing associations with further opportunities to measure the impact of their work. SLLs should have a built-in mechanism so that, with your lender, you can review and amend targets over time. Both parties need to understand why that is necessary, not resist it. 

Be transparent about what you are doing and why. The key is transparency about the approach you have chosen to take. There is no single holy grail methodology. But there must be clarity about the one you are using and be consistent across all the outcomes you chose. So be explicit about it and own how you are measuring your impact.  

At the same time, be humble about what you claim. Attribution is genuinely hard. We have to be cautious about asserting that the changes we report on are solely the result of our work. Deadweighting is part of the answer, but not the whole one. Honest reporting builds trust. Inflated claims undermine it. 

Don’t chase the big numbers. Chose the right outcomes. The proxy value of improving someone’s mental health is five or six times the proxy value of getting someone playing football regularly. But it may also cost five or six times as much to deliver this improvement. The economics matter. Be mindful of the costs of the changes you want to see, but also intentional in what impact you want to achieve. And, critically, base your strategy on the needs of local people.  

This is a partnership. Between lenders and housing associations. Between finance, procurement and community investment teams. Between our sector and those who set and scrutinise the metrics. And most importantly between us and our residents and communities. The more openly we engage across all of those relationships, the better the outcomes for residents. 

The conversation is no longer about whether finance and social value belong in the same room. They are already there. Our job now is to make sure we are making the most of these loans so that we can maximise the impact we make, for our residents and our local communities. 

Wherever you are in your social value journey, we can help.

Get in touch