It would be a brave soul indeed who argued against public sector buyers seeking to achieve social value impact through their spending decisions.
Social value (not defined in the procurement sense but a term that refers to benefits created through public-sector contracts that extend beyond the core deliverables of that contract such as training and skills, local jobs, environmental improvements, community investment, or supporting SMEs) is very much the current “poster girl” of the procurement world. It highlights how public procurement can be used to secure additional value for the public sector purse.
Over recent years, we have seen social value become both a creative and impactful space for public procurement. Public sector organisations and housing associations have been asking for and securing, ever more expansive programmes of social value, involving complex multi-year delivery and deep engagement with communities. In many ways, social value has become the differentiator that demonstrates the contractor’s commitment to driving economic, social and environmental outcomes.
Conversations, however, get interesting when you ask buyers and bidders who pays for the social value outcomes. With the increasing scale and complexity of social value programmes being put on the table, and the growing workforce of social value managers, co-ordinators and specialists now evident across the contractor landscape, this question becomes even more important. And it is this disconnect between what the key players of a public procurement process think about this that we need to explore.
Who pays?
Many public sector buyers strenuously insist that they do not pay for social value, that it is delivered “for free” (out of a bidder’s profit margin?) and is a cost to the bidder that it must swallow to win the contract. Another way of putting it is, “public sector buyer sets the price of entry; the bidder pays it and the community (and/or the wider society) benefits”.
Too often concepts of additionality get confused or conflated when the question of resourcing is raised. The costs of delivering social value are certainly not additional to either the bidder, nor the buyer. Bidders can often be coy about who bears the cost, arguably gaslighted into this position by politicians and practitioners who insist social value is delivered for free. Nevertheless, research has shown that the costs of social value are built into bids through a combination of pricing methods, commercial strategy, and risk appetite. In terms of pricing methods, these include: